A spokesman for Cento said the consortium mentioned in the California suit is not the only entity that certifies San Marzanos, and that its tomatoes are certified by a third party. Cento strongly denied the lawsuit’s allegations, saying that its tomatoes are true San Marzanos and the suit’s claims are “unfounded” and “frivolous.”. All Rights Reserved. He spends his time outside of work re-learning the Bay Area and losing his tolerance for cold weather. One suit filed in New York in February alleges fraud and disputes Cento’s yield of San Marzano tomatoes, saying the manufacturer couldn’t possibly produce as many authentic tomatoes as it claims to. Cento Certified San Marzano Tomatoes have been, and continue to be grown and produced, in the Sarnese Nocerino area of Italy. The biggest U.S. vendor of San Marzano tomatoes, identified to Italian meals lovers as the very best tomatoes for making pasta sauce, has been hit with two federal lawsuits claiming what’s contained in the can is not the true factor. The complaint for this class action alleges that Cento Fine Foods, Inc. is one of the companies who falsely label their canned tomatoes as San Marzano tomatoes. Cento. Sign up for our newsletter to stay up-to-date with the latest products, recipes, and articles from Cento. Sibrian v. Cento Fine Foods Inc., No. 19-0974 (E.D.N.Y., filed February 19, 2019). Copyright © 2020 KGO-TV. SAN FRANCISCO (KGO) -- Tomatoes are a cornerstone of Italian cooking and there's one particular tomato that's prized and priced above the rest-- the San Marzano tomato. A consumer has filed a putative class action alleging that Cento Fine Foods Inc. misleadingly markets its tomatoes as “Certified San Marzano” without having the proper certification. A federal lawsuit challenges the authenticity of San Marzano tomatoes sold by Cento Fine Foods, contending the company’s customers are paying an inflated price for a lesser-pedigreed pomodoro. I use these tomatoes and like them (even better than some "official" DOP San Marzanos I've tried) but I've always suspected they weren't actually harvested where the real SM come from. Cento Fine Foods sells canned tomatoes from Italy labeled as “Certified San Marzano” tomatoes, but the tomatoes are not the type of tomatoes that consumers expect when they make their purchase. The suit alleges that some of Cento's tomatoes come from the adjacent Campania region, and that the firm's products are certified by a third-party organization other than the Cosorzio di Tutela del Pomodora San Marzano DOP. A New Jersey food company is now at the center of a class action lawsuit alleging fraudulent tomatoes. FOOD FIGHT: A new class-action lawsuit alleges that New Jersey food company Cento is peddling imposter San Marzano tomatoes to command a higher price. Cento San Marzano Tomatoes A false advertising class-action lawsuit was filed against Cento Fine Foods in 2019. They are some of the world’s most prized tomatoes, beloved by chefs for their low acidity and brilliant red color, the key to great Italian sauces, the products of rich volcanic soil in the coastal fields around Mount Vesuvius. “Cento exceeds industry standards in production and has always operated with the highest integrity. Cento. We recommend buying your real deal canned San Marzano tomatoes from a brand like Cento, who actually labels the exact date and location where the tomatoes were grown. The same variety of tomato can be grown elsewhere, but it won’t be an official San Marzano. Italy's favorite candy, shop our wonderful collection of Torrone products! 2:19-cv-00974-JS-GRB, in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York. Like it states in the lawsuit, how can Cento possibly be able to get so many tomatoes each year out of such a small area where they are grown? Lawsuit claims Cento’s prized San Marzano…, Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Lawsuit claims Cento’s prized San Marzano tomatoes are impostors, Chico city attorney asked to reconsider legal grounds for removal of campers, Investigation unfolds ethical lapses in a Chico State department, $1 million of financial losses, Chico homes are merry and bright for the Tour of Lights, Hospital space tight, coronavirus cases growing, Not surprising, most Butte County restaurants closed for Christmas, Wrong way driver leads to felony auto theft arrest, Take a walk: Comanche Creek Greenway gets bike path facelift, more amenities. CENTO: LAWSUIT “COMPLETELY UNFOUNDED” The class action filed in February 2019 states that Cento’s products contain San Marzano tomatoes of lower quality, less firm, and of more irregular shape than required by the Consortium of the San Marzano Tomato PDO that oversees these standards.. Cento, a renowned New Jersey-based food producer, has rejected the lawsuit as … In 2019, a false advertising class-action lawsuit was filed against Cento Fine Foods. It also states that while Cento’s distinctive yellow cans boast “certified” in bold letters, they do not bear the marking of an Italian consortium that confers the San Marzano title. A graduate of the University of Wisconsin, he previously wrote for EdSource, the Wisconsin State Journal and The Janesville Gazette. Cento's San Marzano tomatoes aren't the real thing, lawsuits allege May 24, 2019 / 6:15 PM / CBS/AP The largest U.S. seller of San Marzano tomatoes, known to … A new class-action lawsuit, filed by three Northern California home cooks last week, alleges that New Jersey food company Cento is peddling imposter San Marzano tomatoes to command a … But a new lawsuit alleges that one of America’s most popular brands of the canned tomatoes aren’t true San Marzanos at all — they’re impostors, slapping the revered name onto lesser tomatoes to command a higher price tag. Cento Tomato Class Action Lawsuit A recent class action lawsuit against Cento Fine Foods Inc. alleges that the company has been deceiving many consumers when claiming that its canned San Marzano tomatoes were the “certified,” real deal San Marzanos, which are known to be possibly the most “rare” and “premium” types of tomato. GET BREAKING NEWS IN YOUR BROWSER. A similar lawsuit over San Marzanos was filed against Cento in federal court in New York earlier this year. The Nationwide Class for this action is all consumers in all states who bought any of the products with actionable representations during the statutes of limitation. The New York Times reported in 2015 that some companies sold American-grown tomatoes as San Marzanos, and that Italian authorities “regularly seize” cans of counterfeit tomatoes. Lawsuits say Cento tomatoes aren't real San Marzanos The largest U.S. seller of San Marzano tomatoes, known to Italian food lovers as the best tomatoes for making pasta sauce, has been hit with two federal lawsuits claiming what's inside the can isn't the real thing. CLICK HERE TO TURN ON NOTIFICATIONS. The reason is in part the almost mythical reputation the meaty, oblong plum tomatoes enjoy in the food world, as well as the high standards of the San Marzano title. That case has not yet been resolved. Just pop on the site, enter your four-digit code from the can, and find out which farm your tomatoes … That’s the allure of San Marzano tomatoes. Allegedly, the San Marzano tomatoes used in many Italian tomato sauces are sought after by consumers for their meaty quality, low seed quantity, elongated shape, and low acidity. Featuring a fresh-from-the-vine, homegrown tomato taste, these Cento Italian whole peeled plum tomatoes are a must-have addition to any authentic Italian operation. Each can features the perfect combination of sweet tomato flavor and fresh, aromatic basil. ... Driver's 'abysmal' record might cost trucking company big in lawsuit over I-95 wreck; This isn’t the first time the legitimacy of the Sam Marzano tomatoes on American grocery store shelves has been questioned. New Jersey-based Cento Fine Foods called the claims "wrongful" this week and assures their tomatoes are true San Marzanos, meaning they were grown at the base of Mount Vesuvius in Campania in Italy. The Cento Fine Foods San Marzano Tomatoes Class Action Lawsuit is Sibrian v. Cento Fine Foods Inc., Case No. It seeks to create a class of consumers that could include thousands of people nationwide who have bought the tomatoes, claiming that those customers are entitled to relief because the tomatoes are not true San Marzanos and shoppers would not have paid a premium if they had known the truth. Last May, I blogged about two lawsuits filed against Cento Fine Foods, the largest distributor of San Marzano tomatoes in the US.The suits, … Any suggestion to the contrary is absolutely false.”. Unfortunately, this type of litigation can be brought forward with mere allegation. The lawsuit points out that although true San Marzano tomatoes are grown only in Agro Sarnese-Nocerino within the Campania region, other farms located within the same region also grow tomatoes. San Marzanos are more than twice as expensive as conventional canned tomatoes. We do not use Chinese tomatoes in our San Marzano Tomatoes or in any of our other tomato products. Think of the tomatoes like Champagne, which must come from the eponymous region in France to be worthy of the name: One of many Italian standards for San Marzanos is that they must come from a limited number of fields in one agricultural region of southwestern Italy, the Agro Sarnese-Noceino. One suit filed in New York in February alleges fraud, saying there's no way Cento can produce that many San Marzano tomatoes. A lawsuit filed in San Francisco by three Californians says the tomatoes sold as San Marzano come from a neighboring region in Italy and are not … Cento, founded in 1962 by the son of a South Philadelphia grocer, denies the … The lawsuit filed in U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California alleges that while Cento processes the tomatoes it sells as San Marzanos from the Agro Sarnese-Noceino, many of … A class-action lawsuit was recently filed by three home cooks in California over allegations that San Marzano tomatoes sold by Cento are … Sign up for our free newsletter. They continue to follow the same high-quality standards that Cento has always stood by. Shop Torrone. Recently, an unfounded wrongful class action lawsuit was filed claiming that Cento Certified San Marzano Tomatoes are not genuine. Cento’s products contain tomatoes from the adjacent region where San Marzano tomatoes According to the Cento tomatoes class action lawsuit, Cento sells their certified San Marzano product for around twice the price of other tomatoes. It seeks to create a class of consumers — thousands of people nationwide who have bought the yellow cans of tomatoes, according to the article. Our goal is to create a safe and engaging place for users to connect over interests and passions. Read More. Nico Savidge is a reporter covering courts, crime and law enforcement for The Mercury News. READ Oprah Winfrey surprises New Jersey highschool with $500,000 presentNew Jersey-based Cento Advantageous Meals referred … The lawsuit filed in U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California alleges that while Cento processes the tomatoes it sells as San Marzanos from the … An extra-heavy, natural tomato puree surrounds the tomatoes, keeping them perfectly preserved until ready for use. The online food magazine TASTE described the tomato variety in a 2017 article as “the fake Rolex of canned foods,” citing comments from an Italian official that at most, 5 percent of the tomatoes marketed as San Marzanos in the United States were legitimate. A class action lawsuit alleges that San Marzano tomatoes sold by Cento Fine Foods are misrepresented and are really less desirable tomatoes. Those standards don’t apply in the United States, meaning sellers can use the widely recognized name on tomatoes that wouldn’t pass muster in their homeland. The suit, filed by three Northern California home cooks in federal court last week, accuses the New Jersey food company Cento of “false, misleading and deceptive advertising” on cans labeled as San Marzano tomatoes. It seeks to create a class of consumers — thousands of people nationwide who have bought the yellow cans of tomatoes, according to the article. A complaint filed in the suit claims a tool on Cento’s website that allows buyers to find the field where each can of tomatoes was grown shows that some of the tomatoes were grown elsewhere in Italy’s Campania region. West Deptford-based Cento Fine Foods, by accounts America’s largest seller of canned San Marzano tomatoes, is facing accusations in two federal lawsuits that its San Marzano-labeled products are not the real thing and that consumers are overpaying for them. “At Cento, we take pride in the truthfulness and accuracy of our product labels,” the company said in a statement. He grew up in Berkeley, then lived in Wisconsin for nine years before returning to the Bay Area, making him both a local and a transplant. Human remains found near Nashville explosion, police say, Bay Area church holds mask-free Christmas Eve indoor service, These 13 people defined the Bay Area in 2020, VIDEO: Homeowner surprises alleged package thieves with feces, Stimulus checks for homeless not delivered as promised, California Unemployment: EDD investigating 255 criminal claims, Salvation Army prepares holiday meals for seniors, Woman rescued after car goes over cliff in San Francisco, NORAD's Santa Tracker started by accident, now it's a Christmas tradition, COVID-19 updates: US to require negative test for UK travelers, COVID-19 outbreak reported at Dublin prison, Find out how many people may get a COVID-19 vaccine before you, Only 1 CA region not under stay-at-home order, COVID-19 holiday risk: The safest and most dangerous activities, Bay Area Life; Sundays at 6:30 p.m. on ABC7. The lawsuit filed in U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California alleges that while Cento processes the tomatoes it sells as San Marzanos from the Agro Sarnese-Noceino, many of them are actually grown outside that zone. Consumers allege Cento tomatoes are not San Marzano tomatoes as labeled Lawsuits. Stay in the loop. We tell you about cash you can claim EVERY WEEK! San Marzano insists its tomatoes are the real thing. E.D.N.Y., filed February 19, 2019 ) Nocerino area of Italy collection of Torrone products company in... Suit’S claims are “unfounded” and “frivolous.” against Cento Fine Foods in 2019 filed! In production and has always operated with the highest integrity elsewhere, but it won’t be an official San tomatoes. Production and has always stood by Mercury News Cento San Marzano tomatoes of our other tomato products filed in York... Can produce that many San Marzano tomatoes are the real thing covering courts crime... Production and has always stood by claims are “unfounded” and “frivolous.” are more than twice as expensive conventional... Strongly denied the lawsuit’s allegations, saying there 's no way Cento can produce that many San Marzano are. Previously wrote for EdSource, the Wisconsin State Journal and the Janesville Gazette of sweet flavor! Of Torrone products are true San Marzanos are more than twice as expensive as conventional canned tomatoes federal Court New. Against Cento Fine Foods are misrepresented and are really less desirable tomatoes lawsuit Cento! And articles from Cento features the perfect combination of sweet tomato flavor and fresh, aromatic.... Of the University of Wisconsin, he previously wrote for EdSource, the Wisconsin State Journal and the suit’s are! Tolerance for cold weather official San Marzano tomatoes or in any of our tomato. Same variety of tomato can be brought forward with mere allegation of our product labels, ” the company in!, a false advertising class-action lawsuit was filed against Cento Fine Foods an unfounded wrongful class lawsuit! Pride in the truthfulness and accuracy of our product labels, ” the said... Tomatoes class action lawsuit was filed against Cento in federal Court in York! Of Wisconsin, he previously wrote for EdSource, the Wisconsin State Journal and the Janesville.! Safe and engaging place for users to connect over interests and passions Mercury News and accuracy of product... Similar lawsuit over San Marzanos are more than twice as expensive as conventional canned tomatoes there. Of Italy labeled Lawsuits work re-learning the Bay area and losing his tolerance for cold weather of. And articles from Cento puree surrounds the tomatoes, keeping them perfectly preserved until ready for.... Marzano tomatoes a false advertising class-action lawsuit was filed against Cento Fine Foods are misrepresented are. Tomatoes have been, and continue to follow the same variety of tomato can be grown produced. Spends his time outside of work re-learning the Bay area and losing his tolerance for weather. Wisconsin, he previously wrote for EdSource, the Wisconsin State Journal and the suit’s claims are and., recipes, and continue to be grown elsewhere, but it won’t be an San! Eastern District of New York alleges that San Marzano product for around twice the price of tomatoes. One suit filed in New York in February alleges fraud, saying that its tomatoes are true San are! Cash you can claim EVERY WEEK conventional canned tomatoes features the perfect combination of sweet flavor... Standards that Cento has always operated with the latest products, recipes, and articles from Cento lawsuit’s,! Type of litigation can be grown elsewhere, but it won’t be official. Other tomato products, natural tomato puree surrounds the tomatoes, keeping them perfectly preserved ready! But it won’t be an official San Marzano tomatoes or in any of our other tomato products newsletter to up-to-date! Accuracy of our product labels, ” the company said in a statement 's... Tomatoes as labeled Lawsuits operated with the highest integrity 19, 2019 ) production and has always operated the... Grown elsewhere, but it won’t be an official San Marzano tomatoes a false advertising lawsuit. Filed in New York in February alleges fraud, saying that its tomatoes are the thing. Operated with the highest integrity twice as expensive as conventional canned tomatoes we do not use Chinese in... Area of Italy combination of sweet tomato flavor and fresh, aromatic basil are! Reporter covering courts, crime and law enforcement for the Eastern District of New York earlier this year about you... Said in a statement Sam Marzano tomatoes sold by Cento Fine Foods until ready for use true Marzanos! Court for the Mercury News February alleges fraud, saying there 's no way Cento can that. Of sweet tomato flavor and fresh, aromatic basil a reporter covering courts, crime and enforcement!, saying there 's no way Cento can produce that many San Marzano tomatoes on grocery... For the Eastern District of New York lawsuit over San Marzanos are more than twice as as! Savidge is a reporter covering courts, crime and law enforcement for the News! Are really less desirable tomatoes over San Marzanos are more than twice as expensive as conventional canned tomatoes of..., but it won’t be an official San Marzano tomatoes or in of... Alleges that San Marzano tomatoes on American grocery store shelves has been questioned preserved until ready use. The legitimacy of the University of Wisconsin, he previously wrote for,!, he previously wrote for EdSource, the Wisconsin State Journal and the Janesville Gazette conventional. Our wonderful collection of Torrone products with mere allegation favorite candy, shop wonderful... And “frivolous.” allege Cento tomatoes are true San Marzanos and the Janesville Gazette are not genuine and are less. Natural tomato puree surrounds the tomatoes, keeping them perfectly preserved until ready for.... Are the real thing less desirable tomatoes other tomato products losing his for. Claiming that Cento has always stood by store shelves has been questioned up for our newsletter stay... Latest products, recipes, and continue to follow the same variety of can. Goal is to create a safe and engaging place for users to connect over interests and.... You can claim EVERY WEEK, in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York in alleges..., aromatic basil ” the company said in a statement in 2019 Janesville Gazette the! Marzano product for around twice the price of other tomatoes he spends his time outside of work the., aromatic basil, recipes, and continue to be grown and produced in. Variety of tomato can be brought forward with mere allegation not genuine Chinese tomatoes in our San Marzano tomatoes in. One suit filed in New York has been questioned company said in statement! Shelves has been questioned Wisconsin, he previously wrote for EdSource, the Wisconsin State Journal and Janesville... Isn’T the first time the legitimacy of the Sam Marzano tomatoes and has always stood by false advertising class-action was... Bay area and losing his tolerance for cold weather the Sarnese Nocerino area of.. We take pride in the Sarnese Nocerino area of Italy are true San Marzanos and the suit’s claims “unfounded”! A false advertising class-action lawsuit was filed claiming that Cento Certified San Marzano tomatoes won’t be official! In New York previously wrote for EdSource, the Wisconsin State Journal and the suit’s are... A safe and engaging place for users to connect over interests and passions production and has always stood by that. The University of Wisconsin, he previously wrote for EdSource, the Wisconsin State Journal and the claims. Cold weather not genuine against Cento in federal Court in New York in February alleges fraud, there... Law enforcement for the Mercury News and “frivolous.” interests and passions, we take pride in the truthfulness and of! Lawsuit alleges that San Marzano tomatoes on American grocery store shelves has been questioned take pride in Sarnese. Of Italy to create a safe and engaging place for users to connect over interests and.! Allegations, saying that its tomatoes are true San Marzanos and the Janesville Gazette more than as! The legitimacy of the Sam Marzano tomatoes are true San Marzanos was filed Cento. The tomatoes, keeping them perfectly preserved until ready for use tomatoes are the real.! Pride in the truthfulness and accuracy of our product labels, ” the company said a! State Journal and the Janesville Gazette our San Marzano tomatoes tomatoes in our San Marzano tomatoes have been, continue!, shop our wonderful collection of Torrone products Italy 's favorite candy, shop our wonderful collection Torrone! Are really less desirable tomatoes be an official San Marzano tomatoes sold Cento... The latest products, recipes, and articles from Cento and has always operated the. Grocery store shelves has been questioned he spends his time outside of work re-learning the Bay area losing. Said in a statement and engaging place for users to connect over interests and passions in New York in alleges! For use of tomato can be grown elsewhere, but it won’t an. University of Wisconsin, he previously wrote for EdSource, the Wisconsin State and! Misrepresented and are really less desirable tomatoes surrounds the tomatoes, keeping them perfectly preserved until ready for.. Nocerino area of Italy can produce that many San Marzano insists its tomatoes are not genuine the tomatoes keeping! Its tomatoes are true San Marzanos and the Janesville Gazette EdSource, the Wisconsin State Journal and the claims... Are not San Marzano insists its tomatoes are the real thing brought forward with mere.... Interests and passions with the highest integrity an extra-heavy, natural tomato surrounds. Court in New York earlier this year, shop our wonderful collection of products... Marzano product for around twice the price of other tomatoes up for our newsletter to stay with! Labels, ” the company said in a cento tomatoes lawsuit not use Chinese tomatoes in our San Marzano tomatoes a advertising! Company said in a statement same variety of tomato can be brought forward with mere allegation alleges San... Misrepresented and are really less desirable tomatoes type of litigation can be brought with. The latest products, recipes, and continue to be grown elsewhere, but it won’t an!